N

Nisan

27 karmaJoined Apr 2024

Comments
4

CSER and Leverhulme, which I think are institutions that have overall caused more harm than good and I wish didn't exist

I'd love if you could comment on which concrete actions were harmful. (I donated to CSER a long time ago and then didn't pay attention to what they were doing, so I'm curious.)

You might be interested in Building Human Values into Recommender Systems: An Interdisciplinary Synthesis as well as Jonathan Stray's other work on alignment and beneficence of recommender systems.

Since around 2017, there has been a lot of public interest in how youtube's recommendation algorithms may affect individuals and society negatively. Governments, think tanks, the press/media, and other institutions have pressured youtube to adjust its recommendations. You could think of this as our world's (indirect & corrupted) way of trying to instill humanity's values into youtube's algorithms.

I've seen a few proposals for a world without power structures, and they've all had glaring theoretical problems. They don't have great answers to all of:

  • What if there's a bad harvest?
  • What if someone gets cancer?
  • What about children?
  • What about people who don't like the system?

If I saw a description of a way of organizing society without power structures and that addressed all of my theoretical objections, I'd start to get interested.